Shedding a Traditional Approach to Assessments
It is the first day of class and students enter the course
with a dread of failure. Usually
homework and learning opportunities offer only one chance to define their grade
which will be more damning and permanent than Hester’s scarlet letter.
This is often not a fault of faculty being lazy. They simply
do not have the time to make the work better and afford students multiple
attempts - effectively offering the students a chance to improve. Nevertheless,
this results in students dreading assignments and fearing failure.
As an alternative, we should view failure as an opportunity for students to assess the situation and
progress. One is reminded of John Stuart Mill’s line in chapter one of his
autobiography:
‘A pupil
from whom nothing is ever demanded which he cannot do,
never does all he can.’
never does all he can.’
Learning should be thought of as a way to improve and one
does this through multiple attempts. If
you do not succeed at first, you try again – often using different strategies
to learn how to solve a problem.
Discouraging students from trying new solutions, even though
some may fail, is doing them, and ourselves, a great disservice. If we adopt
the mindset that students should have the opportunity to experiment and explore
solutions, we may not only find that they will be more open to try harder
problems but that we are fostering creative problem solvers. This requires that we consider creating
learning
activities that allow for multiple attempts. These attempts will offer opportunities to
assess and improve.
This is one of the keys to the success of the gaming
industry. Gamers recognize that they
will fail in their attempts. They also
know that if they keep focused, try multiple times, and often have to think
innovatively, they can overcome the challenge. The ability to save progress or
use a reset button is not a coincidence. It allows for multiple attempts to
test various strategies.
By allowing students
to participate in learning activities multiple times so that they can improve
their skills, we are fostering a non-defeatist mentality that will benefit our
students. Students can explore options, review feed back and see how the lessons they choose to adopt directly affects their success.
We are also mirroring actual learning environments where
people must experiment with strategies to determine which will succeed and to
learning from their mistake.
Another important feature of viewing Learning as improving,
is that we are encouraging a sense of agency in the students. Their decisions matter and what learning
strategies they employ will directly affect their success. This will contribute to their success both as
a student and as a person.